International law is a set of rules that governs the relationship between subjects of international law, i. If police actions were proscribed, and individual discretion were kept in check, abuses of that discretion would be drastically reduced. The uses and abuses of police discretion department of. Because of their discretion, authority, power, and solidarity, and union protection, some police officers come to see themselves not as simply enforcers of the law. In addition to that, an adjudicator has power to decide whether or not to impose a sanction ii.
Not every nj town abuses public employee compensation practices identified in the sci report, but far too many still do. In this essay, i first provide a brief overview of the history and evolution of police. Police are not soldiers who must blindly follows orders. Police discretion allows law enforcement officials to effectively make decisions in the field when no clearcut solution is illuminated by law or a handbook. A national study of police officers attitudes has been formatted for the web in pdf format. Discretion is the capacity an individual police officer possesses to make a choice among a number of possible courses of actions. Understanding discretion in modern policing thomson reuters. See united states attys manual, rico guidelines preface 9110. The consequences of police discretion in the police 1199 words 5 pages. Cities across the country are debating police discretion. Police must be more than competent at applying the rules. Essay on proper use of police discretion 2124 words.
While many incidents of domestic abuse will go unreported to the police, for victims seeking criminal justice intervention the police are usually the first agency of contact. The national institute of justice is a component of the office of justice programs, which also includes the bureau of justice assistance, the bureau of justice statistics, the office of juvenile justice and delinquency prevention, and the office for victims of crime. Understanding and controlling police abuses of force, edited by gellar, w. Essay on police abuse of discretion 2738 words bartleby. Traditional characterizations of the police culture have focused on describing the shared values, attitudes, and norms created within the occupational and organizational environments of policing paoline, 2004, p. National institute of justice national institute of justice research report t d e p a r m e n t of j u s t i c e o o f f i c e f just i c e p r o g r a m b s j n i j d p b j s o v c broken windows and police discretion. Abuse of the discretionary power can be alleged only to reverse a decision and not to allow it. It will not discuss every area of judicial discretion.
Whether or not an officer decides to stop someone for a traffic violation or prevent an assault, does not involve the use of discretion but the establishment of priorities. Police discretion in contemporary america bernice b. Primary sources of international law are international conventions, international custom and general principles. Toward harm reduction policing katherine beckett introduction although discretion is an unavoidable and ubiquitous feature of police work, it is also the subject of significant controversy and debate. Create a list of ten actions during which an officer might use discretion and why. Police are what is known as streetlevel bureaucrats. This basically means that police are civil servants working on the street level in direct contact with the general public enforcing the laws of the local, state and federal law. Abuse of discretion is one of the reasons a court of appeals may use to reverse the trial court. In this essay, i first provide a brief overview of the history and evolution of police discretion from the 1960s to today and explain how its exercise has been impacted in recent decades by the war on drugs and the adoption of broken windows policing. Reports from human rights watch told that since september 11 attacks, more than 70 men were put in prison without any criminal charges.
What are ways in which police discretion can be used. The focus here is on judicial discretion, and the abuse of it. On the other hand, police officers can abuse their discretion by consistently making law enforcement decisions in favor of certain groups or individuals. Abuse is the improper usage or treatment of a thing, often to unfairly or improperly gain benefit. Abuse of discretion legal definition of abuse of discretion. The abuse of administrative discretion law teacher. Forming suspicion and making a stop abstract most police activity occurs in private, away from the publics view. The misuse of police powers in officerinvolved domestic. This creates a situation that allows police officers discretion in the way they think about what they see and how they handle those with whom they come in contact. Abuse of discretion law and legal definition uslegal, inc. The set of element that were used include victims of human rights abuses and the police.
The abuse of police authority as this study reaffirms, commitment by the chief and command staff to uphold democratic values and eradicate discriminatory practices is key. Moreover, reports from the washington post said that complaints against new york police department have augmented by 60 percent in the span of four years. Police discretion is a constant consideration within police services. For the sake of those who are not familiar with this concept, as a law enforcement officer, we have the power to use our own discretion to be creative in enforcing the law. The first major check on the discretion of judges was the jury. Can someone help me find examples of police discretion. Panzarella 2003 suggests that organizational control of police discretion is a facade because police officers are an uncontrollable entity and that an increase in. The abuse of police authority this edition of the abuse of police authority. A national study of police officers attitudes has been formatted for the web in pdf. In the second half of this essay, i argue that since police discretion. Abuse of police authority national police foundation. I have no idea about what police officers do besdies serve and protect please can someone help me. Since these powers can be easily misused for personal or political. However, some research has begun to investigate the assumptions associated with a single police culture.
It articulates three familiar value models of police work that can be used to examine the uses or abuses of knowledge about the consequences of police discretion. Discrimination is also a fact of life whether it be race, dress, attitude, or. Police officers decision making and discretion ncjrs. Discretion is the opposite of routine and habitual obedience. Although discretion is an unavoidable and ubiquitous feature of police work, it is also the subject of significant controversy and debate. A judge, holding office over the course of multiple cases, and selected by appointment or election, is susceptible to undue influence. The fourth chapter or s ection of this stud y is the data presentation and analysis. This discretion allows us to not arrest someone who we might have probabl. A difficulty here is that the term discrimination has two quite different positive and negative connotations. It is seen by many to be both an essential part of policing as well as a constant source of issues.
Yet, this clearly does not eliminate the possibility of abuse of power and wrongful use of police discretion as the disproportionate application of justice upon those of lower class and of minority races is fundamentally present in both lesser and greater crimes. Probably the most wellknown example of such change has to do with the policing of domestic violence and child abuse. Police discretion is a fact of life but lets not confuse discretion with assigning priorties. Unfortunately, the police have an ability to perform an abuse of discretion without being noticed or regulated by the judicial or legislative community in. Police administrators should proactively institute and enforce strong policies governing conduct, as well as systems to collect and analyze data relative to policecitizen. The abuse of administrative discretion takes a number of forms for instance, acting on mala fide grounds, ignoring relevant considerations and acting on irrelevant ones, making decisions without cogent material and misconstruing the power granted by law. Administrative law judges have discretion to abstain from participating in a legal proceeding due to a conflict of interest of the adjudicator i. The ordinance also establishes a deputy inspector general for public safety, who is charged with auditing the entire police accountability system and identifying patterns that violate residents constitutional rights.
Abstract police officers legitimately have broad powers of discretion to enforce the law. Policing the police is a very important part in maintaining a balance of police discretion and controlling it so the power of discretion is not abused. The phrase the thin blue line is often associated with the police. Abuse of discretion occurs when a court does not apply the correct law or if it bases its decision on a clearly erroneous finding of a material fact. The misuse of police powers in officerinvolved domestic violence page 3 2015 2003 diane wetendorf, inc. The essay concludes that, in light of this regulatory history of. Policies with respect to the exercise of discretion by police are understandably often controversial, and may change over time in response to changing public attitudes. A court may also abuse its discretion when the record contains no evidence to support its decision. Police accountability copa, which is scheduled to replace ipra in 2017. This article describes the problem that experiments in police discretion may solve, the experiments themselves, and the problems their findings may create.
Where a trial court must exercise discretion in deciding a question, it must do so in a way that is not clearly against logic and the evidence. Bryant, hubert williams 2001 this report presents the results of the first truly representative national survey of how americas rankandfile police officers and their supervisors view critical issues of abuse of police authority. A national study of police officers attitudes by david weisburd, rosann greenspan, edwin e. How to maximize your chances of showing an abuse of. A police officers ego and a citizens ego would not clash and create a violent situation. Discretion among the lower ranks in policing organizations makes control by the organization imperative so that the operational decisions represent the organizations values. This trend in police work has many advantages such as allowing officers the flexibility to handle each situation in a manner that best fits its individual needs.
The misuse of police powers in officerinvolved domestic violence page 1 2015 2003 diane wetendorf, inc. Determine whether the use in each action is reasonable or an abuse of power. This thesis discusses police exercise of discretion and its relationship to the u. To these descriptions, one can also add the kantian notion of the wrongness of using another human being as means to an end rather than.
This time, act on public employee compensation abuses. Issues such as the potential for racism, sexism and socialism are everpresent in everyday policing. Situations like the current controversy in ferguson and countless others would be prevented. Department of justice office of justice programs 810 seventh street n. Abuse of discretion a failure to take into proper consideration the facts and law relating to a particular matter. These are, in particular, states, public international organizations and individuals. Description for patrol officers because they make decisions that produce actual police policy as it affects citizens decision to arrest makes them the gate keepers of the criminal justice system. It means that police in their blue uniforms often act as a line between lawfulness and illegal acts. Police officers legitimately have broad powers of discretion to enforce the law. It brings knowledge, skill, and insight to bear in unpredictable ways.
785 1494 1441 1503 940 217 1031 1103 82 1136 519 1012 402 1155 1093 1268 1505 759 1417 728 624 1396 1349 349 459 620 149 344 1392 495 627 480 1308 818 841 795 1499 102 502 367 94 841 24 177 869 469 602